Follow
Share

My sibling and I have already decided not to have a public funeral for our father when he eventually passes. He basically has no friends still living. His remaining siblings no longer visit or call him because they are mad at him for one reason or another. And the list of reasons why not to have a funeral goes on and on. My sibling and I just can't see the point in having a public funeral for our father when we don't think many people would attend. And those who might show up, we don't want to be forced to put a smile on our faces when they say "your dad was a wonderful guy" blah, blah, blah. In all honesty, my sibling and I are angry with our father for treating us the way he has over the years and especially the past few years after his mild stroke. I feel like dad's siblings might be mad at us for not having a funeral (if they are still living when dad passes) but I don't really care if they are mad. Does anyone else feel this way?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
I have pre-paid for my mother’s direct cremation.

She has no friends here, and the family are all just pleading with God to take her already. This dementia is just soooo hard to watch. She hates her life, and we hate it for her.

If there is any money left in her estate, I will use my portion for us all to go out to dinner and celebrate that her suffering is over. Please, God, make that sooner, rather than later.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
Geaton777 May 2022
I pray every night that the Lord would take my aunts (ages 100 and 103) peacefully in their sleep. Every. Night.
(4)
Report
See 2 more replies
Where I live the vast majority of people are cremated. I think it is around 80%, perhaps higher. So memorial services are the norm, not funerals.

When Mum goes I will have a service at her Church, just as we did when my step dad died.

For Dad's 90th birthday my brother hosted a catered birthday lunch at a community hall. We had over 100 guests including students he taught 50 years before. Dad is 93 now and very frail. I am glad we were able to host that party prior to Covid restrictions.

Grandma1954, I have found over the years that there are people who make an impact on our lives, yet their family may never know what it was. Going to the funeral is a way of honouring the person they were.

When my great Aunty Jessie died, I had not seen her in decades. She had been moved by her family away from my community. When the memorial service was held for her, people were asked to share a story. I shared my story about baking birthday cakes for my grandmother (not her sister, other side of the family), every July. None of her kids, nor grandchildren knew that story.

Yes, she died after suffering from dementia and being bed ridden for years, but before that she was quite a wonderful woman who baked cakes with a little girl. She actually taught me to love baking.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Funerals are for the living not the dead.
Personally once I am in that box I do not particularly care what the family does.
I would much rather they and friends visit me while I can still enjoy their company. I would actually prefer that anything that would be spent on a funeral be used to pay someone to come in a deep clean the house so it can be sold then family and friends can have a party with what little bit might be left.

I will say I had no idea what my Husband would have wanted because he refused to talk about things like this. I mentioned once to his sister that I would probably have him cremated and she told me that he always said he wanted to be buried next to his mom. So that is what I did. When I went to the funeral home and planned the funeral I said, 1 day wake and burial since I did not think anyone would come. I was actually blown away by the number of people that showed up, a few even flew in from across the country for just a few hours.
The thing that got me was...all these people are here now where were they the past 5 to 10 years?
Bottom line do what you and your immediate family wants to do.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I hear you. My Mom lives near to the Ocean. Never allows me to drive her past. Screams at me when I make the suggestion. Says she will never understand people who want to live near it. Couple times lately she says she wants her ashes to be sprinkled in the Ocean. Not going to happen. Etc....
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
WhisperingPine71702 May 2022
Thank you...glad I'm not the only one.
(1)
Report
My 92-yr old mother has not even ever mentioned her own funeral. Ever. She is in somewhat of denial about her mortality. She knows she has no friends (and never has). Her family members are her "friends". She was my single mother and I have no siblings but she lives next door to me and my sons are very fond of their Nonna. For their sake I will arrange for a very intimate "goodbye" to her ashes, in FL at the beach we all grew up visiting and have many fond memories (fyi we'll do it from a boat and her ashes will be contained in a small concrete figure which we'll deposit over the other man-made reef off the beach). Then I'll probably go out for crab legs and oysters washed down with some dirty vodka Martinis for our memorial dinner cuz that was her favorite thing to eat. I'm asking for the same for my own goodbye.

Regarding your uncle being upset... If he's so concerned then he can come visit his brother while he's still alive.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I think funerals should be held to help the people left behind to mourn.

As his children, *YOU* get to decide what kind of funeral - if any!! - to have for dad. If his distant relatives have that much of a problem with you choosing to not have one for dad, well, I guess they'll just have to get over it, won't they? I mean, they always have the option of arranging one themselves, but I have discovered that the people who would give you the most grief (no pun intended) about not doing the "right" kind of funeral are the last ones who would be willing to spend one penny and/or one millisecond planning it themselves. No, they'd rather try and lay on a guilt trip where you arrange the funeral so they can come to the event and look "properly tragic".

Even *if* your dad had been the most happy-go-lucky, easygoing type of father, that still wouldn't oblige you to having a funeral if you and your brother didn't want one for him. And you know what else? You don't owe *anyone* an explanation of why you and your brother make the choices that you do in regard to any sort of service once dad passes. I think it's a highly personal decision, and for anyone to question it or criticize it is beyond tasteless.

(((hugs)))
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I think COVID has shown us we don't have to have full funeral services. A lot of people are opting out for cremation then having a memorial later. I have told my girls I don't want a funeral. I definitely do not want a viewing. I am being cremated and if they want a memorial service that is up to them. They can just have a nice dinner on me.

If Dad has money put aside for his burial than go thru the coffin and stuff. You can do a graveside service and those who want to come can. You can offer a luncheon if you want or you and sister can go out just yourselves or not at all. If there is not that much money, then cremate him. Then do what you want. I would not tell anyone what you plan on doing before hand. When the time comes, just tell those that matter that Dad passed. I have seen very short obits where it just says so and so passed.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

My sibling and I decided that and my partner and I decided that. Neither of us are religious. If someone in the family decides to do a potluck and throw back a couple of drinks, that's great. As Thomas Lynch, the poet and undertaker says, I won't care, because the dead don't care. Once dead, he says, there is nothing someone can do FOR us, TO us, WITH us or ABOUT us. Hee hee.
If you feel bad for Dad's siblings, have a nice get together some time after things settle. Let them know you will do so. Who knows, they may say "Don't BOTHER" and then you won't have to bother.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Not having a service for my mom. It’s just me , here… my mom will be cremated and sent to another state to be interned with my father. There will be no service there, as I can’t justify the huge cost for two sisters to say goodby…
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I didn't have a funeral for either of my parents and I'm sure they wouldn't have cared. They followed me to Texas from Ohio 40 years ago and had a small (almost non-existent) circle of friends here and there was NO way I was hauling them up to Ohio to have a funeral with family who never came to Texas during some of their most serious illnesses.

I had a family only viewing so my mom could say goodbye to my dad died simply because he was in an SNF for rehab when he died and she wasn't able to visit him. My mom died at home (her choice) on a Sunday and my son found 'cremations-r-us' and for an extra $100 (since it was Sunday) we got a pickup that night.

If your dad's siblings want a funeral, they can make the arrangements and pay for it. A funeral given out of obligation is like getting flowers on Valentine's day from a husband who despises you, yet knows flowers are expected. It's NOT the thought that counts here. You and your sib do what works best for you and the heck with everyone else.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

See All Answers
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter