Follow
Share

I would like to know if you're the durable power of attorney and guardian of a family member, can another family member make the choice of a DNR for the one that you're over when the hospital knows I was her POA and said they would have to ask me? I said she was to get CPR or whatever she needed and the hospital failed to listen to me and she coded and they didn’t do CPR. Is that legal in Alabama to do so? They wouldn’t let me in to the hospital due to COVID in March when she died she was 59. Myself, mom or other siblings did not even get to say bye ! I don’t see how the hospital can make that decision when they knew I was her durable power of attorney and guardian they spoke with me numerous times and told me what son said but she had me put over her in 2015 ! How can they do stuff like this ?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
I'm so sorry for your loss in such traumatic circumstances! May you receive peace in your heart.

I need to ask some questions so others can provide better support and suggestions to you:

Can you please clarify if you were PoA - or - guardian? You're either one or the other, not both.

58 is very young...why was she in the hospital in the first place? What were the circumstances of her medical problems?

How did the hospital "know" you were her PoA? Did you provide the legal documents to them?

If you were not allowed to be in the hospital how do you know that they didn't do CPR or take enough measures to save her life? Maybe she had a Living Will on file that had a DNR?

Not that it makes your loss any less awful but many people on this forum lost loved ones in facilities without being able to be with them.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Soalone85 Nov 2020
I know all this because one nurse I spoke to is kin to my other sister by marriage! There for she and I called each other over my sisters well being! The hospital had the legal paper work that listed me over her! When I spoke to another nurse she told me they didn’t do cpr or anything when she coded cause her son said don’t do it! My sister had been on a ventilator 2 times before kids wanted her removed off that would’ve killed her she came out of it came home that was around 7 years ago ! I don’t just give up on my family or someone I love cause it’s inconvenient! I would’ve been with her if they would’ve let me in the hospital as it was she died asking where I was ! They put her in a coma to help her rest her body the medicine they was giving her lowered her bp and she coded they told me that over the phone!
(0)
Report
See 3 more replies
Maybe she was considered competent and this was her choice?
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Soalone85 Nov 2020
No she wasn’t! She was listed mentally incapacitated and she new she had problems and trusted me to take care of her like I had been doing! We have a big family there’re 6 of us I’m the youngest of all of us and I held that responsibility cause I love my sister! The lawyer mailed all 3 kids a letter they sighed stating they didn’t want any part in what I had to do! I don’t see how they can come in and make life decision when my sister went to a lawyer on her own had all the paperwork drawn up and talked to me about it ! No one wants to go through what that puts on you but I did it out of love for my sister! She wanted to live we was planning a trip when she got better ! What’s the point in paying a lawyer to make sure your wishes and life is being looked out for!
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
It can become complicated ,decision, but in general the answer is that "Yes, a doctor may refuse to do CPR on a patient" if professional concensus is that the patient cannot live, is too ill to live, and the procedure will cause further injury only. A patient doesn't get CPR until they are dead. To attempt to resuscitate is a "heroic measure", and you can read that as "trying to bring someone back from the dead.
As a Nurse I often thought, when families insisted on CPR because they could not let go of a loved one, that they had to stay at the bedside during it. It is nowhere as pretty as you see on TV, nor anywhere as successful. I am so dreadfully sorry for your loss. In today's world this is a very young woman. You were not at the bedside, but as I understand a son was. I wonder if you spoke to him. At any time did your mother refuse CPR/DNR?
I am sorry you are grieving. Sometimes we stay in this "argument" about what was done and what wasn't in order to face the fact, the mourning which is so devastatingly difficult. I hope that you will find peace.
Did a doctor ever speak with you? Did he suggest that your Mom's case was hopeless. Because in all truth, when things are hopeless, CPR can amount to battering a person's body. True enough they are gone, and it is unlikely they can feel it, but it is quite a devastating process.
I wish peace for you, and hope something will happen to help you over this hurdle, and to bring some understanding.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
AlvaDeer Nov 2020
I Apologize, Soalone, I see this was your sister, not your Mom. I am so sorry for your loss of her. I hope you will come to peace with time.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Like Geaton said, you can't have POA and have Guardianship too. Guardianship overrides POA and to get it you need to go to Court and find the person incompetent to handle their own finances and health.

When you have POA it is not "over" someone. The person has assigned you as their representative. The decisions you make are based on the wishes of the person who assigned you.

Read your POA, is it immediate or Springing when the person can no longer make an informed decision. If Springing and your sister was competent to make her own decisions, then ur POA was not in effect. Which means your sister was still in charge of making her own decisions. Signing off on her own DNR. Did you make sure the hospital had a copy of the POA on file? Telling them over the phone is not enough. Son is considered closest living relative over siblings.

I have a feeling sister was terminal. Like Alva said, CPR does not always work.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Soalone85 Nov 2020
They didn’t know what was going on that’s why they was running test the doctor said he would be able to tell me what was going on and what he could do for her when all the test was run
(0)
Report
My sister had it drawn up for me to be her durable power of attorney! She was on a ventilator 2 times in the past kids wanted it removed I said no we’ll fight for her she came back that was about 7 years ago when that happened! She didn’t tell the hospital she wanted an dnr that’s what I was for she had some mental issues that they was aware of and yes the hospital had the records on that! I couldn’t get in the hospital due to COVID my sister was put in a coma so she never told them dnr her! I was told she was improving! I spoke with a nurse at the hospital she said she would me mad as hell to! They didn’t know what was going on with her that’s why they was running test to see what was our next step! As far as me not being allowed to be her guardian as well the court did that too that’s what she request in 2015’ the nurse I spoke with said that never should’ve been allowed the hospital told her son that I would have to make that call and they called me and I did ! The medicine they was giving her was lowering her bp that’s what made her code they told me that but chose not to do cpr on her! I don’t see what the point in making dpa if someone can decide they don’t want to follow it! It wasn’t my sisters intention to die I promised her we would get her better and she would come back home as before! She never got that chance because it was made by the hospital they dropped the ball on this and didn’t fix her chart like they was supposed to I know one of the nurses personally and she didn’t get that put in the chart after speaking with me! It wasn’t my sisters or my fault I wasn’t allowed in the hospital to be with her check on her and the care she was receiving!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I have read your responses. So sorry you had to go thru all of this. I saw nowhere where u say what was wrong with your sister. Trying to care for a patient when family cannot be nearby is hard. Your not be able to be there was hard. I think when hospitals open up again, you need to sit with the DON and find out what actually went on with your sisters care. There is a reason CPR was not done. Or was done and and it did not work. You cannot always get the heart restarted.

It may come down to there was nothing that could be done for sister. Her heart stopped for whatever reason. Things happen. I know that is not a comfort to you. But sometimes there are just no whys. You need to know that you and those carrying for your sister did their best in a very difficult time.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I’d ask the doctor what happened and why. I know that nurses have a lot of knowledge, but I have also known nurses that make mistakes, or try to say what they think someone wants to hear, particularly after a death.

The important thing now is that your sister is at peace, and that you need some peace too. Dwelling on this, considering a medical negligence claim, making public criticism that leads to a defamation action, can all turn a sad situation into a never-ending nightmare. It could also destroy everyone in the family, if people take sides. Please let it go.

Almost everyone has some ‘if only’ feelings after a death. If you are a believer, give this problem to God.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter