Follow
Share

My mother in law lives with us and I’m having a hard time getting her to respect my boundaries in regards to my time, in the past I’d respond quickly to her every request but now I realize she’s manufacturing issues in order to get interaction/attention. I am busy and have a life and cannot entertain her all day, and no longer want to enable this dependency. For example, she will interrupt me working to ask where a pan is, or where something in the fridge is , without even looking. I will tell her, I’m busy now maybe look again? Etc but it seems she’s pushing back. Another example, she will ask if she can help with something and then ask the most ridiculous questions every step of the way, like is this how you want it? Is this enough? Etc. It is like she is forcing me to stay with her, when the whole point is to take a chore off my hands. or she will drag on basic conversations. For example, does the food need salt? I reply no it’s good. She will literally keep asking, so it’s good? Doesn’t need salt? Etc etc
how can I gracefully curb this attention seeking behavior? I also have young children who she will literally talk over with her unnecessary questions. I've tried being direct and isn’t working
I should add I’m also an introvert who needs my quiet time, and rarely has any. So I find this behavior extra difficult because I feel my needs are not being considered, only hers.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Having read through the comments, esp your responses which give more examples, it sounds like your MIL is in the earlier stage of dementia. The various things you report that she says and does are often typical in the early stages. Repetition - yup. Can't locate something despite it is always in the same place/area - yup. Not wanting to go out/do things independently - yup. Not being able to work microwave, coffee pot, dishwasher despite being shown many times - yup. Seeking attention, sometimes.

You also implied this has been gradually getting worse. This likely rules out UTI, although it can't hurt to check. Usually the UTI will cause more abrupt changes in demeanor or behavior. She really should have a checkup and assessment for dementia/cognitive decline. Some regular doctors are not very good at this, but you could start there. Our doc tried giving the test to my mother, even though she had already been living in MC for 2+ years (couldn't even complete much of it) and when I went later for my checkup, I had to take the test too! It does, at the least, give a baseline. If you don't think the regular doc would be useful, you could take her to a neurologist for testing/assessment.

If this is dementia, which I do think it might be, she isn't doing this deliberately, nor can she "help" herself. Think of when your kids were toddlers, trying to learn things and be "helpful" - often they can't find things, ask questions over and over, seek more time with you, etc. This is how dementia is. The sad part is toddlers will eventually learn and grow, become more independent. With dementia, the process is in reverse. She WILL regress more.

You should get hubby involved in this, since it is his mother and you can't tackle this alone. Both of you need to learn more about dementia, because it won't get better, it will only get worse. Being armed with knowledge will make this "journey" a bit easier (just a bit), because you will be more aware of what to expect as it progresses.

The repetition is mainly because short-term memory loss is one of the first symptoms (it was for me - I had to do my research as I knew nothing about dementia at that time), so they don't remember that they just asked/said something. It's like a record getting stuck on a scratch. Sometimes you can "bump" it along, but it will get caught on another scratch later. Although using controls is more long term memory, there is also the issue of becoming unable to follow instructions - it gets jumbled so trying to operate something, or sometimes trying to follow a recipe, they find they can't figure it out, even something they have done or made for years.

So, recommendation is to get an assessment done asap. While waiting for appt, start learning the stages of dementia. It is helpful to know what you might encounter (the stages are guidelines, not everyone gets every symptom and not everyone gets them in the same order.)

I don't think she is a good candidate for IL and may not be for AL either, She may need MC, but during this current crisis, there isn't likely going to be a place that would take her in. You mention something about this not being doable. If family objects, then they need to take care of her instead, to see for themselves. If she has no real assets or savings, you would have to consider Medicaid.

But, start with getting a checkup/assessment. Until you know for sure whether this is dementia, you are working blind.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

You don't have to answer her every beck and call if the questions are just attention seeking and you are sure that's what she is doing. Handle those kinds of questions as you would if your children were asking for the same reason. There are only so many hours in the day and if you are busy doing something more important then just ignore this behavior or tell her you don't have time at the moment to deal with that question. You might also need to talk to your husband about it if you haven't already since this is him mother. Maybe he could help out more or talk to her.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I've had this happen with my late mother so many times. I barely had time to eat a meal (actually never did SIT down to one - just grabbed a bite while running past) and mother had NOTHING to do. She also, like your mother, talked over people. Prayers to you. Gently keep redirecting her to, e.g. look again in the frig.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I experienced something similar,..literally drove me to health issues,twitchy eyelids,dangerously high cholesterol levels.I looked about 10 years older within 2 years.Every good thoughtful thing I did was smashed down,everything I repaired around the house they broke it soon after,..they'd lie and be sneaky.
All I can say is you perhaps are in a damned if you do or don't situation.It's a tough one,.as they need you,..but I came to realize I was literally killing myself to save someone else :(
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Good morning!
the answers given are all helpful.
Yes, please help your mother in law have a medical check-up from a good geriatrician. Some GP's will not be able to detect if she has dementia.
She would not change. Placing her in a respite care/nursing homes can conserve the good relationship among the people in the house. Before you know it, you will be exhausted and you can be pushed into being disrespectful to her and you would not want your children to see that. Good discussion and planning with your husband regarding his Mom is also in order.
Mean time, you can try giving her tasks which will interest her so she can be occupied. Make sure the task will not require complex thinking because she will not pursue doing it. Example, allow her to fold clothes and make her put it in another room every time she finished folding one. This will also be an exercise for her. This is just an example, know what she would want to do.
Safety should be in your mind also. I hope this helps.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

You won’t be able to change her. I had to move my mom out of my house just to get her to start doing for herself. Which she is some now. She still try’s to manipulate. They will never change. You have to protect your kids and your relationship. They will be grown and you don’t want them to resent grandma taking all their time with you. You have to give yourself the peace of being able to say no I’m sorry I can’t do that. It’s hard not to feel guilty. I think it’s just an evolution of our relationships over time. We can carve out time in a week and tell them this will be your time and then the rest of your time will be for you and the kids. Good luck.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

She can't stop. So, ball is in your court and "gracefully" probably won't work.
As hard as it sounds, ignore her. Say, "I can't talk now, Mom, I'm concentrating on something." Just put her off until she gives up. Remember when your kids were young and you had to say "no" 100 times before it stuck? It's like that. Persistence and patience. Don't show your frustration, just answer each time like it's the first time, "sorry, I can't help you now (or talk about that now, etc)."
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Sounds like me! I had my mother live with us for 3 years. I am a very patient person. But one day I couldn't take it anymore I said tomorrow we are going to look at places and you are moving out on a month. Then I did all that
Independent living and assisted living are very pricey. First go MIL financial advisor. He can tell you how many years worth of money she has to live on
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

You will not change her behavior, she seeking involvement, companionship and attention, things you cannot give as much as she needs. My mom did the same thing but it was In can’t find this or that’ and it was right next to her.
what you need to do is change how you respond to her. If she wants to do something point to a clock and say we’ll do in 15 or 30minutes. It’ll keep her occupied watching the clock. It also sounds like she has onset of dementia, not remembering she just asked that question and you just need to be patient. And empathetic. Imagine yourself looking at the world thru her eyes. Jigsaw and crossword puzzles may help her be more focused on something besides you entertaining her time.
And remember the sooner you find answers the better because she will continue and it’ll get harder for you. But you are sharp, smart and resourceful and you CAN do it.
love and light
Sabrina
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Anon, I would get her checked. Everything that you say leads me to believe that she is having mental decline.

Not knowing where the pan is, even though it is in the same place for 15 years is an indication of dementia.

Once you get her diagnosed it will be easier for you to understand what is happening, but the behaviors will not change. So maybe it is time to reconsider the living situation, because she can't help what is happening to her and she obviously bothers you a great deal, it either works for everyone in the house or it doesn't work.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

You said she "can’t figure out how to use the microwave, coffee pot , dishwasher ect even tho We have shown her a million times over the years. I even made Labels and videos! I want to be empathetic I do, but I feel the more If I give an inch she takes a mile.
could this be an early dementia sign? Or just loneliness" I believe from your descriptions it is probably a combination of both. Often seniors in early stages of dementia start forgetting how to do simple things--operate a remote, use their cell phone features, operate a microwave, etc. Watching a video and/or reading instructions don't help because that part of their brain is broken. They also can't figure out things to do to entertain themselves. I had someone explain it to me is that it's a backwards regression of skills---So your MIL is very similar to a 5-6 year old at this point when it comes to those things. She will continue to regress. Maybe you need a family meeting with your husband and then add in your MIL and come up with a routine for her that you can write down and start enforcing to build some good boundaries? Times you are available and times youre working? Let him take some of the responsibility of "filling her tank" with attention in the evenings. Maybe a walk, maybe a 30 min time for them to do something together--go for a drive, something to help her fill that tank. ALSO the not going out is also a red flag. She feels unsure of her abilities to handle the social situation. It's possible she is having more issues that you are seeing and she's using all her effort to try to cope/hide those deficits.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

A friend of mine took her mother to “adult day care” everyday. Maybe you could check local area agency on aging to see what activities are available for your MIL. I think you can even get transportation... lots of things going on for seniors to get involved in! Good luck. Being an introvert myself, I totally get that you not only want time away but need it!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Is dementia occurring and is it possibly caused by meds so called?Not every old person behaves childishly. In my generation none of them did.Now so called old age dementia seems to be pandemic and it is obviously hard to cope with it. I am so glad I can live happily alone at 86; and other people seek my company rather than the other way around. My heart aches for thehelpless needy old people like this M in L. I dread ever becoming one of them.I wish I knew the answer to this apparently ever increasing problem.How I wish this tragic M in L could live alone and seek out companions who would appreciate her.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Does your “manipulative, attention seeking, time consuming, etc.” MIL add to your home financially or is she without financial support? Have you discussed this bothersome MIL with your husband
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

She may be bored/lonely, has early dementia or depression, or needs purpose. A trip to the doctor will rule out medical problems. See about her connecting with other people via Zoom or Skype of the phone. If she is able to sew, let her make face masks for the local hospital while listening to the news or music. Something along these lines should help your loved one be a little less clingy.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Is there a chance that it is premature dementia? The questions sound very basic. Does she need assessing? Sometimes what we think is deliberately antagonising is a symptom of something else. Good luck.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Isabelsdaughter Apr 2020
I agree with wiseowl
(2)
Report
anonymous871557, I can't reply to your private message because your profile page doesn't allow messages to be sent to you! If you go to your account settings you can change this if you would like to.

The only thing I'd say, though, is that one of the great things about the forum is the range of views and ideas that people contribute. I hope you're already feeling at least not alone in your situation. Best wishes,
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

It is possible that the two of you are just mismatched, you know. It doesn't have to be all because of her manipulative attention-seeking behaviour, or because of your introverted personality. Plenty of people are perfectly nice in themselves but get on with each other much better at a certain distance.

You say you've been dealing with her "for years"? How many years? And what's changed that makes you less able to tolerate her now?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Apr 2020
CM,

Thanks for pointing this out. I have felt the same. So many times people feel that someone is being manipulative when they aren’t. They simply have different personalities.

Remember that book from years ago, ‘What Color Is Your Parachute?’ People were using it to determine compatibility.
(2)
Report
See 3 more replies
Hariver, it's good to get strategies, attempt boundaries, etc., but, unfortunately, with senior parents, it's often not feasible when they are living with you. They are set in their ways, may have cognitive inability to process information, and have no incentive to do anything different. People are't prone to change late in life. So, I would think that counseling for yourself might help. You can check out yoga, meditation, spiritual guidance, music, fitness training. All of these things supposedly, help us eliminate stress.

AL may be affordable, even if you think it isn't, based on various factors. I'd explore it to see.

Last year, I had a senior friend who became very bothersome with some of his behavior. I tried to set boundaries, explained my position, stood my ground, etc. But, his behavior did not change and I could not tolerate it. The friendship ended. I later discovered that he was like that with everyone else too and had always been that way, though, it was hidden from me for years. I'm glad I didn't suffer dealing with him for very long. It was emotionally draining and very painful. We all know how much we can take. I hope you can find some peace.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Late 60's? Some folk are still working but I get that many housewives worked in the home, not outside.

Yes to all the suggestions that she needs to find her own life, interests, hobbies.

Once Covid is over & social groups are allowed again, I'd be finding a local senior centre with activities she can attend multiple days a week. Reminds me when my daughter was 4 - chatting all day, needing my help for every activity, wouldn't do anything for more than 10 mins on her own. Kindergarten was a lifesaver. 4 days a week she was occupied, learning & social & I stayed sane.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
anonymous871557 Apr 2020
Yes it’s very childlike behavior , and I’m not sure if this neediness is part of aging or she’s choosing to sort of give up on her own life.
many ppl suggested putting her in AL, but for many reasons that’s not an option. I really just need help with coping mechanisms, how to deal with the attention seeking behaviors & how to make my boundaries clear so I can get my own needs met
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Your mother n law is in her late 60’s? She could live another 25 more years!!! Do you want her in your house for another 25 YEARS??? Move her into a facility!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

You tried having your mother n law live with you. It didn’t work out. Start looking for a facility before she ruins your life and your marriage. She could live for YEARS!! My mother is 95 1/2. I will never live with her and she will never live with me. She lives alone in her own house.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

You are being polite to MIL, and it is backfiring on you. Be less polite. Say ‘Please be quiet’. Then just ignore her. Worth a try, to see what happens?
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

hariver18 - reading what you wrote here and what you wrote in your other thread,

https://www.agingcare.com/questions/caring-for-needy-mother-in-law-how-can-i-accept-this-wont-change-456914.htm?orderby=recent

all I can tell you is that you can not change her behavior. YOU MUST GET HER OUT OF YOUR HOUSE. If you don't, she will ruin your family, your marriage, your life and your children's lives. She is like a cancer in your home. Eventually, the cancer will kill the host.

Find her another place to live, senior independent living communities where there are people her age, and plenty of programs to keep her entertained, and plenty of people to talk to and make friends if she so chooses.

As for you question of how you can gracefully curb her attention seeking behavior? Gracefully, NO. You invite more of the same behavior by being graceful.

You can try to bluntly tell her "I need quiet time right now."
You can bluntly tell her "NO, I don't need any help."
"NO, I can't talk right now."
You can tell her to "please stop asking questions."
You can tell her "your questions are giving me a headache."
You can bluntly tell her "please do not interrupt when I am talking." or "please do not talk over me/your son/your grand kids.' then give her the 'look' and hold your gaze until she looks away.

Will she feel uncomfortable with the above comments? I would hope so. That might encourage her to keep away from you or better yet, move out of your house.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
Llamalover47 Apr 2020
Hariver18: I get that - it is very hard to live with someone. I had to live out of state with my late mother. Prayers sent to you.
(0)
Report
sadly, sounds like my mother :(
My mother has always wanted attention, even if negative. She has pushed away everyone around her. siblings dont call, or visit. One aunt sticks by her and I am not sure as to why. Mom is always throwing the past in her face (and everyone else).

I joined today with hopes of getting advice or just to find support. I dont even know where to begin. :(
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Kittybee Apr 2020
Post a "question" describing your situation. Soon you'll have lots of helpful responses!
(1)
Report
This current situation is making everything harder for everyone. We all know that.

She is who she is. You are who you are. You can’t change her. No one has that power. She may be lonely and isn’t an introvert.

You are an introvert and would appreciate your privacy. It’s hard for both of you. Even if two people have compatible personalities it is hard to cohabitate.

When things settle down discuss this with your husband and perhaps you should look for other living arrangements for her.

Other than that, maybe she can find a couple of friends to interact with once or twice a week.

In the meantime, if you don’t want to answer her questions then simply walk away. Where is your husband? Is he interacting with his mom or is it mainly your responsibility to care for her? Ask him to participate with her.

Best wishes to you and your family.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Sounds like it's time to get MIL out of your house and into a place of her own. Independent Living if she's capable of it, or Assisted Living if she's not. Of course, right now with a pandemic on our hands, nobody's moving anywhere. But it's a good time to plan your next move, the way I see it. Talk to DH and see how he'd like to proceed with moving his mother out.

People who are seeking attention constantly are not going to change, they are only going to get worse and worse with age and as dementia either progresses or develops, let's face it. Give her chores to do or projects to work on, I guess, but don't expect the questions to stop............this is apparently part of her personality which generally doesn't change, especially if she doesn't see that a problem EXISTS to begin with. Most of them don't.

Growing up in a house with my grandmother was THE worst childhood ever. All my mother did was fight with her, and the histrionics were unbelievable. I actually kept a notebook for when the 'men in the white coats' came to take my mother away, they'd have a log of behaviors to diagnose her by. That's not to say your situation is even remotely like mine was, or that your children are being subjected to such a stressful environment, but it's something to consider about their lifestyles as well. Everyone suffers when there is discord in the house.

I like Gemswinner's idea to put on a nice pair of HEADPHONES which is your way of saying you're not available for your MIL. But then again, she could wind up tapping you on the arm to ask her questions ANYWAY, who knows? With my mother, she'll make herself known no matter WHAT. She has GOT to be the center of attention at any cost. Fortunately, she lives in Memory Care so she's using her attention getting strategies on others. I only have to deal with her drama on the telephone, which is bad enough, I'm sorry to say.

Is there any way at all that she has enough mind power to get onto a computer? If so, you can set her up with games like solitaire or Facebook or the games offered on Facebook, etc. If she has the ability, she may spend hours and hours each day on the computer getting lost in the maze of stuff to do, and Oh Boy Wouldn't THAT Be Nice? :)

Wishing you the best of luck moving forward.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I'm an introvert, too. I put on headphones (the big kind; I bought some MPOW from Amazon for under 50 bucks). I use them to work out, and even if the battery happens to die in the middle of a workout, I just keep them on. The charge keeps for a really long time, by the way (at least three weeks for about an hour a day use). You could just point at them and smile when she's babbling on about whatever, yet you know you can still hear your kids or whatever it is that you actually WANT to hear.
I listen to books through my audible app, and music or the radio through i tunes; you just need to have bluetooth; super easy to set up. It says to the world, " NOT AVAILABLE", but as I said, you can still hear what you want to hear with them on, but you only need to acknowledge what you want to hear (like the telephone ringing, and your kids; you can even talk on the phone with the headphones in place; weird to get used to, but useful).
I'm sure lots of people have more therapeutic interventions which don't seem so....well, introverted and antisocial, but it might be worth a try!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
anonymous871557 Apr 2020
Thank you I might need to actually wear headphones
i do listen to music or watch other things on my phone and half find time she gets the message, the other half speaks right over it
headphones would be a more visual cue
(3)
Report
Is it possible she might live in an apartment near you ? Does she have funds of her own ? She might enjoy having friends her own age , and you need a break .Where is your husband in this mix ? Will he be willing to talk to her ?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

If she won't go out, she may lack confidence, have social anxiety or feel that she's not able to conduct herself the way she wants to. My mom has bladder incontinence and she's embarrassed she'll have an accident, even wearing protective underwear. There's usually some reason they don't want to go and get involved. Oh, both of them tire easily, so, they want to go and chat, but, they get tired and have to return home. Of course, they can talk like a storm on the phone! OMG. Could you find her some people to talk to on the phone all day? Lots of seniors enjoy that.

I just thought of something that I saw on a news story once. I think the person needs to be pretty healthy cognitively, but, there was this senior who was very bored during the day. He started calling people on their birthday and sang them Happy Birthday! He did this for years! I think it might have been the people in his church or maybe, in his town, but, lots of people loved it and got calls from him every year singing Happy Birthday. I thought it was a very inspiring story of what one man did to make a difference. He said it kept him very busy.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter