Follow
Share

My 94-year-old dad has advanced Alzheimer’s. After my mom passed away, we kept him at home and had different people caring for him through the day and night. But we had to move him due to the house not being conducive for a walker in too many trip hazards. He also became more combative when anyone tried to get him to do something he didn’t want to do. He has been living in an assisted living facility for almost 9 months. He fell a few times at night in the beginning, so we have hired a private person to stay with him overnights when the staff does not check on him that often. He is in continent now and uses depends. He is now at the point where he wants to just sit and sleep in his recliner and very seldom get up to use the bathroom, even with help and go to dinner. He now uses adult Depends and gets aggressive at times when they try to get him up to go change him so the staff does not force him to do anything, and he may sit in his recliner in a wet depends for many hours at a time. We have been fortunate that he doesn’t have any sores. We kids are very involved, and at least one of us goes by every day and spend a few hours with him, usually at a mealtime when they are just bringing his food in to the room and setting it on a TV tray when he refuses to go to the dining room. We help him eat. He’s not verbal but does interact through different sounds and expressions. We are lucky if they can get him to allow them to give him take a shower at least once a week. But we still we can enjoy him and laugh with him, and he seems to be happy.


My question is, with his declining abilities. I’m thinking they will soon want us to move him into a true memory care facility. They haven’t said anything yet, but I’m thinking a memory care may have more staff to check on him, be more equipped on handling him and keep him from sitting in wet depends for so long. Does a memory care force the resident to get up so they can change him and shower him, even if they are combative? Do they use more medication to pretty much drug them, so they are more acceptable? What have you guys seen in the difference between a memory care and assisted living? Up to now we have really liked the assisted living facility. I just think dad is going to need more care soon. And then I’m wondering if we are still going to need to keep the private person overnight in the memory care Because dad likes to get up and walk around and we’re afraid he will fall? Or do they keep a better eye on the residents? What has your experience been between assisted living and memory care? Thank you so much.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
My Mom was in AL for a short time as respite. While there, it was diagnosed that she was better suited for MC.

MC has additional staff on hand to do medication management, bathing, incontinence, ensure that the person has eaten enough, help that person eat, deal with the "needy" behaviors as well as locked external doors. My Mom's MC also does laundry (included in the basic fee), wellness checks (extra fee). Her one complaint is that she does not have any "friends" in MC other than the caregivers. However the truth is that my Mom, and others on the ward, are unable to sustain a friendship. My Mom can no longer comprehend the written word in sentences. She can read individual words and know what they mean, however, cannot comprehend when put together. Other people in my Mom's MC have memory related disorders like food obsession, Parkinson's and memory loss due to some other medical condition. The caregivers also check in more frequently to ensure she is okay (not fallen) and in this facility, ensure that she gets at least 1 hour a day of face-to-face individualized conversation.

AL on the other hand allows for more independent living. Those people are able to sustain friendships, know the difference between clean clothes and dirty clothes and can tell when they need to go to the toilet and most of all, are not people who lose track of where they are.

So to specifically answer your questions:
1. In our state, any resident can refuse medication. In my Mom's case, after 3 times, they quit trying and tell me. If she was in AL, they would quit trying and not be required to tell anyone.
2. Yes, in MC, they check for incontinence. However, that is also true in AL, for a fee.
3. Getting up changing and showering: That is true with any extended care, not just MC. It is also true of Skilled Nursing Facilities.
4. If your father is combative, they have 2 options: 1) talk to you to have a doctor diagnose the condition 2) no longer allow him in the facility. These options are available whether AL or MC. In AL, there is less tolerance for combative behavior
5. Medication can not be prescribed without a doctor' authorization. Many of these facilities have doctors on call, and it is up to you whether they call the doctor without your knowledge or whether you continue to choose an outside doctor. In my state, no facility, hospital or other, can give medication without a doctor's authorization, even if it is a vitamin.
6. My Mom used to get up a lot at night and is a fall risk. They put a bed monitor on her to let them know when she got out of bed and that way they would know when to check on her. We trained her to pull the cord first, before getting out of bed. That at least gave them some warning. This was a large reason why she had private care at home at night, prior to going to MC.
7. Yes, at least at the facility we have chosen, they keep a better eye on my mother than at a AL or even me. In addition, I don't have to worry about getting meals for her, cleaning up her messes and being 16 hours a day entertainment. My mother can no longer comprehend what is being said on television, however, even though she has no friends, she likes watching what other people do and say. That is her entertainment.

I highly encourage you to start touring and researching MC and AL facilities. Many have waiting lists. If you are private pay, you will have more options than someone who is "government pay". When I put the numbers together, I found out that staying at home was more expensive that going to MC or AL. However, I live in a place where cost of living is quite high.

Good luck in your travels and it is great that you are asking those questions now, rather than when you are forced to place him....which could happen if you wait for a "horrible" fall.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Where my mom was for Memory Care there was staff in the kitchen that prepared meals for the next day during the night shift. That way they could see and help anyone who wandered around at night. Assisted Living had someone in the building, but they were sleeping and only looked in on everyone once during the night. In Memory Care they were more able to care for the incontinence issues too, as just about all residents had that need. It's more expensive because they provide more care. Your dad doesn't seem to need locked doors, but that's one of the amenities of Memory Care, as many late stage dementia people wander. Also, in Memory Care the nurse comes more often. Falling still happens.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Our Vermont facility provides both assisted living and memory care sections. Memory care provides most of the additional needs you report. Staffing there is claimed to be 3x that needed in assisted living. Believeable, seems sufficient and is expensive. Valley Terrace in White River Junction.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Skelly1230: Your father requires memory care now.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

My stepmother was in AL, we had to move her to MC, she is doing just fine, she gets more attention and is safe in lockdown.

She started roaming and dumpster diving, collecting rocks, sticks, metal, dead leaves and more, so off to MC she went,

Same building. We had to move her last year as we had to stretch her money, She did just fine with move, she didn't even know that she was in a different home.

I took her out to lunch and my brother moved her.

We are happy with her care!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I’m glad to hear comments praising some memory care units. My observation is not positive. My sister was moved from AL after being told (in CA) that her testing resulting in a dementia diagnosis REQUIRED that she be moved into Memory Care. She is now in a locked unit - completely unneeded as she has never wandered. The unit is dingy and staff ignores her when in her room. She has had a bad fall at night, resulting in hospital stay. The MC staff do not check her at night to prevent falls. The family has to hire private pay staff to be with her at night.
Her cognitive functioning level has gone down since this move.
Question: is it true that a dementia diagnosis in CA means a newly diagnosed person must be in MC?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
geddyupgo Jul 2023
So sorry for your experience. I have no knowledge of CA laws but I have to say it sounds strange to me.
In NJ the it's the symptoms of dementia rather than the dx. that dictate where you reside. Many of our residents had a dementia dx but you wouldn't know it just looking at them or chatting with them. They were able to participate in most of the regular AL activities. It was only when they started to wander or could not keep up with the regular activities that they were moved to the secured MC unit. Yes.... the staff on that unit had more dementia related training and the staff to patient ratio was greater so aides had more time to cajole residents into bathing or toileting. Continually aggressive residents were a danger to both staff and residents and they were sent out for psych evals right away. They could not come back until the hospital got the med cocktail right. Rooms were bright as were the moods of the residents. Even some good places are suffering from staff shortages now after covid. Nursing staff - RNs, LPNs and CNAs just burned out. Moreover, while I am the first to admit that the industry is an expensive one in which to operate, most of the private entity onwerships are funneling the bulk of the fees received to the owners. A bit trickles down thru administration (admissions, marketing) and maintenance (lots of money spent there because that entrance hall has to look great to entice you in) but by the time it gets to the nursing staff and the CNAs (they are ones doing the grunt work, cleaning feces and sometimes having to duck to miss a swing) that trickle is just mist in the air. While you don't have enough money for me to take a CNA job, I think you would find a few more people who would be willing to try it if they got $20/hr and there was career ladder for upward mobility,( not just the big leap from CNA to RN). Additionally, the backlog in processing the admission of legal immigrants into the country is also affecting the staff situation because many immigrants will find a way to afford the CNA certificate and start their careers there. If your current facility has an MC, I'd follow what others have suggested and tour that (try to tour at least twice.... once at mealtime to see what staff is available and what they do). If they don't have an MC then it would be wise to start looking for other facilities now. As someone suggested, perhaps check out your Office on Aging or state Dept of Health for a listing of home/board residences that may be available. This is not an easy journey for anyone but hang in there... you will get through it.

As an aside to this question and to show you what money can get you both as a resident and in terms of staffing....went to a facility over 15 years ago somewhere in VA (I will try to get the location but they don't advertise.... don't have to).... totally private pay with only 10 medicaid beds. If I had money, I'd shoot myself so I could go there! It wasn't nice.... it was fabulously awesome! Went there at the request of the activities director as they were having a "hunt ball" for the residents (many of whom had fox hunted or played polo in their lives) and he wanted some " fox hunters to come galloping out of the woods on their horses to enjoy the morning "stirrup cup" drinks before we galloped off into the woods to pursue the fox. That evening (early at 5 pm) was invited back to the "ball" . A few people was slowly shuffling to the music '40s and some aides were "dancing" with some residents including those in wheelchairs. One guy was like Fred Astaire... great moves and danced with everyone. All the ladies (including the Medicaid residents) were in formal gowns with jewelry and makeup. The gents were in black suits or tuxes. The food was unbelievable. I tried my best to convince them I was a resident but they made me leave! It is still a beautiful memory for me. Lowest pay there was $16/hr. at that time!
(2)
Report
I got off the elevator at the wrong floor of my mom's assisted living and it was the memory care floor. It was nice and bright and had beautiful views of the grounds. No smells, quiet, smiling aides. Also I often saw patients from that floor out with aides, strolling the building or going in and out. I was impressed. This was in Florida. It was run by Brookdale.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

You are thinking about it in the right way. Memory care facilities have skilled staff who know how to care for and interact with residents that have all stages of dementia and declining abilities. They check in more often during the night and they know how to help with toileting, bathing and dressing, taking medications, also feeding. Some of them have male aides and nurses. They have a 24/7 nurse(s). The nurse can order equipment as needed. For example, when my mother had advanced dementia they got her a hospital bed with bars so she wouldn't get out of bed on her own (she also lost strength in her legs and kept falling). They also ordered her a safe and comfortable reclining chair (called a geri chair). They'd help transfer her from bed to wheel chair when she could no longer walk. Some men prefer to have male aides. It's still a good idea for the family to visit as much as possible. If it's more than they can handle (for example, if he is a big, heavy man) they may have to transfer him to a nursing facility, where they have equipment to lift people out of bed. But this should be a last resort. Try to keep him in memory care if they can handle it. All the best to your father and family.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Prayers to you, Dad & your family..A tough stage in The Circle of Life, exacerbated by this disease.

My Mom was in MC 3+ years, passed in 2021..A lot of experience here. Bottomline, I would move your Dad to MC, keep your private duty nurse, bring Hospice in & put a camera in the room..The more “hands-on-deck,” the better..

Mom’s facility was very clean, but always short-staffed, under-paid. The good aides almost always started in MC, then moved to AL side..So frustrating!

Lmk if you want me to expound..You/family are doing great with your Dad. He feels your care & presence. ❤️😇🙏🏻
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

My father passed away before needing memory care but I had toured a few and for people living in the SF Bay Area I can say I was very impressed by the memory care facility Carefield in Pleasanton CA. It was very spacious and bright with a large protected patio area for residents. The entire building was built in a circle so all the hallways led back to the large central gathering area so residents could never get lost. The food looked very good and the chef made fresh bread a few times a week. There seemed to be a good staff to resident ratio and the rooms did not look like institutional rooms. They looked like someone’s bedroom and bathroom at home or a nice hotel room. I toured a few others that were a hard pass right away so this one really stood out.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

" Memory Care" is skilled care 24/7.
" ALF" Assisted Living Facility, has different level of care expectations defined; in other words , the patient is cognitively appropriate and can perform ADL needs etc.
Talk with the facility and they can give you the " level of care needs' description for each level of care. You may also want to go ahead and have the patient 's PCP provide an updated assessment of pt care needs so that you can be pro active instead of waiting for the facility to make the call. And, of course, start being prepared for the increased cost associated with " Memory Care" vs "ALF".

Practice good self care !
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

My 90 year old mom with mid/late stage Alzheimer’s has been in MC for just over a year and it’s been a very positive experience. We kept her home as long as we could but eventually she needed more care than we could give. I’ve read some dreadful responses here and I’m sad that people have seen such horrible conditions in certain MC facilities (i know it exists) but it’s not fair to generalize. Our MC is extremely attentive, they toilet mom every two hours and check on her every hour through the night. There are activities happening all day and many of the residents participate and engage. There’s chair yoga, sing-alongs, arts and crafts, history lessons, etc. (The list goes on)… I have been very impressed, overall. I visit everyday and see it for myself. There are some amazing MC facilities out there; it’s just a matter of finding the right one. They’re not all terrible.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
salina95 Jul 2023
This is my same experience with my mom in memory care. I always stop by unannounced and I’m quite pleased with the facility. Yesterday they were meditating, it was very peaceful. Other times, they’re playing a game, singing, learning, therapy dog visits, guest musicians.
(4)
Report
See 1 more reply
My father moved through independent living to assisted living to memory care in the same facility. I never noticed a smell in memory care but maybe there was odor in the rooms of the few bedbound residents. The cost was a bit more in memory care than in assisted living. There was a large man who was sometimes combative for awhile. The staff often had two people working with him to get him to move from one activity to another. I would suggest visiting all the memory care facilities close to your home. Have lunch with the residents if possible, You will get a feel for the staff.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

My wife and I moved to an ALF because of her dementia. One year later she developed incontinence and needed to be moved to MC … we live in San Francisco and our facility has both AL & MC in the same building. Both are bright, clean, with wonderful caregivers. Lots more help in MC than in AL. Lots of activities in both. Cost is roughly comparable in both. I still live in AL and see my wife whenever. I haven’t seen, heard, or smelled any of the things others have posted. Guess we've been very lucky!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
ElizabethAR37 Jul 2023
Yes, from what I read/hear, I think you have had good luck on your side. In addition, you probably have the financial resources for a top-of-the-line facility. I suppose there are good and not-so-good facilities at every price point, but yours sounds exceptionally well run.
(1)
Report
Have you considered a board and care home?

I would look into that before the AL gives you notice.

No place is going to force dad to do what he refuses, it's the law. However, a good aid can get seniors to do what is needed and that is important.

I prefer the smaller board and care that offer services until death. They don't have the activities that larger facilities have, they feel more homey, tend to have less turn over in staffing and it is easier for people to get to know one another, among other benefits.

As hard as it is, sometimes we have to see and say, it is good enough because there are no good options. We do the best we can and pray that it all works out without to many hiccups.

Oh, one thing to be mindful of, maybe, dad has pain and he should be changed in his bed or recliner, he may be more receptive to that vs getting up and going to the bathroom.

Best of luck, this is a tough situation.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I can tell you from a long experience working in caregiving that the only real differences that memory care offers and assisted living doesn't is a locked door and memory care costs a lot more.

The residents don't normally get any better care then they do in AL. They definitely use more drugs in memory care because it's often necessary when dementia worsens and someone gets more violent, aggressive, and combative.

If you've never been to a memory care (formerly known as a dementia unit) be prepared for the experience.

For starters memory care facilities, wings, units, whatever they're calling them are going to smell. I have never seen one that didn't stink of pee, crap, soiled bedding/clothing, and unwashed people.
They're usually very dingy looking if not downright dirty even when they are located within a rehab, nursing, or AL facility and the other areas are very clean and well maintained. The memory care parts usually aren't.

The residents in memory care usually smell and look like their hygiene isn't kept up on as well as it should be because it isn't. They also don't offer the level of baby-sitting services you may be expecting for people with dementia either. Residents wander into each others' rooms. They take each other's belongings. It is not uncommon for a resident to be wearing clothes that aren't theirs too.
Be prepared for what you will see and know that this is what memory care is.
If you have to place your father in one, keep that aide you hire privately for him.
Helpful Answer (14)
Report
ventingisback Jul 2023
Great advice!
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
I have seen a lot of memory care units in my role as a hospice volunteer. I have yet to see one where the care level is higher than a regular ALF wing. My experience (just mine, in a wealthy county in a wealthy state) has been that they are the grimmest places on earth. The smells are worse, the cleanliness is lower, the staffing is less, there are almost no activities or one-on-one interactions except for the most basic care. Patients are more confined because of their risks. Some are strapped into a wheelchair. One day, I went into the "activity room" and there were 8 people in wheelchairs, pointed at a blank wall, while an aide played on her phone.

I'm sorry to be the voice of doom here, but please, be sure you know what you're getting. My sister works at a very posh facility in another state, and the care level is much better, but even then, she has to chase down aides to change people, etc. (She is an admin, not a health care provider.)
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
BurntCaregiver Jul 2023
@TeethGrinder

You're not being the voice of doom here. You're being the voice of honesty and reality.
(10)
Report
I am amazed that an ALF will keep your Dad now that his needs are so advanced. Generally such a resident takes so much caregiver time from others who are more suited to ALF, and is disturbing for them to witness. I would imagine your Dad has also risen to a level 4+ care needs and there is a lot of expense, perhaps as much as memory care.

Doe his current ALF have a wing that is for MC patients? If not, then I can see why they are "hanging on to dad". But if they do have a facility for MC I would guess you are close to their asking you about this advancement.

You are so correct that they are much better staffed in MC for your Dad. He may also qualify for Hospice care help and that is a help to the facility.

I am so sorry you are at the place for these decisions. I wish you the very best of luck.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter